Welcome to Discussion Hub

Discussion Hub is a general discussion hub helping you get a little blast from the past. Enjoy coloured usernames, special userbars and a tight-knit community.

Should Churches Pay Taxes?

MrDawn

Moderation Director
Moderator
Joined
Aug 31, 2029
Messages
5,523
Reaction score
180
Points
93
Hubux
$680
Winbux
$0.00
Do you think Churches should be required to pay taxes? Why or why not?
 

FriendlyPerson

Making a name for themselves
Joined
Mar 7, 2021
Messages
223
Reaction score
51
Points
58
Location
Eastern US
Hubux
$1,731
Winbux
$1.00
Depends on the church, I don't think they all go for non-profit actions.
Agreed if they aren't of non profit nature they should be paying just like Amazon should be (in most cases, Amazon in 2019 actually didn't turn a cent in profit so they were able to legally and ethically spared being taxed).
 

MrDawn

Moderation Director
Moderator
Joined
Aug 31, 2029
Messages
5,523
Reaction score
180
Points
93
Hubux
$680
Winbux
$0.00
Yes. Churches abuse the money they get in "tithes". Most do not use it to help the poor or donate it. Religious Missions turn into family vacations. Because of this, most churches are violating the Lemon Test and Establishment Clause therefore they should be forced to pay. I think the US government needs to make the church system pay up.

Religious organizations across the United States have received at least $7.3 billion in forgivable government loans from the Paycheck Protection Program. The top loan recipients are, of course, of the majority religion. Megachurches with outspoken Trump-supporting pastors have received millions of dollars in loans, and churches tied to sexual abuse and financial scandals also took advantage of the free money.

This is a clear violation of the Lemon Test and of the Establishment Clause. The grants given to churches obviously do not have a clearly secular purpose, so it fails the first part of the test. The handouts advance the interests of the religious organizations that receive them, and I’m not sure how anyone could argue that the aid does not create unnecessary entanglement between church and state.
263fcd3ab5179d45d2a8452d3a9430040a250c6d.jpeg
 

TopSilver

Making themselves at home
Joined
Sep 29, 2020
Messages
66
Reaction score
14
Points
48
Hubux
$1,755
Winbux
$0.00
I suppose they should if by law they had to. The majority of churches by law don't have to pay taxes and just because they may be making money on donations, doesn't mean they're required. However it really comes down to the law because everyone is expected to follow the law.
 

Empire

Kicking
Joined
Jun 2, 2020
Messages
6,373
Reaction score
484
Points
113
Location
United Kingdom
Website
www.baysidegamers.com
Hubux
$7,963
Winbux
$201.00
It's A Me, Mario!
The tax church movement is more of an anti-religion / atheist thing than a legitimate source of getting income. Churches operate as a non-profit organizations just like the Salvation Army and Goodwill. The main focus and target of this anger are towards these so-called megachurches, which are actually fewer than what people believe.

Heck in my city there's a church inside an old store.
 

Ash

Founder & Former Owner
Diamond Member
Joined
May 30, 2020
Messages
8,135
Reaction score
1,571
Points
143
Location
Your Backyard
Hubux
$3,875
Winbux
$0.00
Wake Up To Reality!
FSociety
Yes, I don't see why any religious organisation should be exempt from taxes, to be honest. But like Empire mentioned near the top, they should probably focus on the big corporations not paying enough tax first (Amazon, Google etc.)
 

Kylie

Wild Thing
Diamond Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2021
Messages
8,346
Reaction score
939
Points
143
Location
USA
Hubux
$12,569
Winbux
$512.00
RAINBOWWWW!
Catch That Pokémon
Bill Gates... No, Kylie Rich
Whenever one entity is exempt, others pay. So really, there is no such thing as exemption, when another takes the burden. If the justification for the exemption is charity, then give credit to charity organizations but still tax churches. I don't understand the concern is that churches would want representation, they already have tax exemption and freedom to practice religion even without paying taxes, what more would they want?
 

Ashlynn S

Has big shoes to fill
Joined
May 16, 2021
Messages
674
Reaction score
165
Points
73
Hubux
$2,683
Winbux
$0.00
The tax church movement is more of an anti-religion / atheist thing than a legitimate source of getting income. Churches operate as a non-profit organizations just like the Salvation Army and Goodwill.

Do they all though, I think there are a lot of churches that are far from non-profit and a lot of preachers/pastors/priests/whatever-they-are-called who are making a LOT of money.

Yes, that isn't the case for the more 'traditional' churches, but it does seem to be the case in a lot of others.

Disclaimer: I am an atheist and believe that organised religion is responsible for more cruelty, hatred, and bloodshed throughout history than anything else, but still strongly support everybody's freedom to believe in whatever they choose to.
 
Top